Steelers PATs: Grasping for defensive answers

Andy Dalton's fourth-quarter fumble Sunday was recovered by Arthur Moats. -- GETTY

Andy Dalton’s fourth-quarter fumble was recovered by Arthur Moats at the Cincinnati 24. — GETTY

DEJAN KOVACEVIC, DK ON PITTSBURGH SPORTS

CINCINNATI — One last look at the Steelers’ last game …

• This won’t be yet another spanking for the secondary. Those are stale and, what’s more, to borrow Mike Tomlin’s adverb of choice, this team’s pass defense is obviously the problem at hand.

So how to fix it?

The simple answer is that it can’t be done. Which it probably can’t. It’s too late in the season for external moves, there really aren’t any internal youngsters to promote, and the backups are worse than the starters, hard as that is to fathom.

At safety, Shamarko Thomas has potential, but he’s played exactly zero defensive snaps this season — it’s stunning to me how even some diehard fans are unaware that he’s appeared solely on special teams — and Carnell Lake strongly suggested to me last week he’s anything but ready to be tossed into a role that pivotal. Quarterbacks read off the safety. It’s their No. 1 focus at the line of scrimmage. When the safety messes up — as Troy Polamalu did, in particular, on Andy Dalton’s embarrassing 20-yard touchdown jog in the Steelers’ 42-21 win Sunday — it’s easily exposed and usually with devastating results. That’s not a smart risk at this point.

Will Allen would be my choice to replace Mike Mitchell, but much more based on his steady showing as an emergency starter last season than this season, when his minus-3.1 rating in pass coverage from Pro Football Focus is almost as lousy as Mitchell’s minus-4.9. At least Mitchell has modestly upgraded his run defense.

Is that move worth it?

Or is it making a move to make a move?

And don’t even bring up benching Polamalu. His work Sunday was worse than just what was exposed on that Dalton run, but let’s deal in reality. Not going to happen. Ever.

At corner, here’s one move that must be made: Antwon Blake must start over Ike Taylor, even if Taylor’s bruised knee heals quickly. This can’t be even slightly optional. Blake has played only about 20 percent of the Steelers’ defensive snaps, and only 113 of those have been in pass coverage. But he’s been targeted 25 times and allowed a catch 15 times, a 60 percent rate that’s actually decent on this team, plus he’s got an interception, four passes defensed — one of them a beauty Sunday on a deep ball to A.J. Green — and, in the less measurable sense, he just looks fresher out there. He looks aggressive. He looks like he’s ready to defend like he means it.

Don’t misunderstand, please. I’m not suggesting he’s Mel Blount. Keep it all in context.

Brice McCain can be involved, too. Leave Willie Gay alone. He isn’t Blount, either, but he does more good than damage. McCain can spell Blake or Gay.

Best thing the Steelers can achieve in the secondary, and I hate to go this simplistic, is to play better.

But it would help, too, if they grasp reality. Cue Mitchell …

I appreciate his taking the fall for Taylor — and yes, wise guy, he literally fell on that play — but this notion of just eliminating a handful of big plays is … again, I’m running out of adjectives.

• All right, you knew I couldn’t resist: Mitchell did get his hand on the ball that Blake impressively batted away from Green, but it does not count as a pass defensed. That goes to Blake. Thus, Mitchell remains a zero in that category as well as interceptions. His minus-1.8 and Taylor’s minus-1.9 ratings brought up the rear for the pass coverage grades.

I want to emphasize here, out of fairness, that when I was writing that Mitchell hadn’t laid his hand on a football, that was in the air. He does have two forced fumbles this season.

• Last point on this front: Sometimes a corner just looks like he’s had a bad day. Taylor was targeted 10 times — telling in and of itself — and conceded nine catches for 141 yards and a touchdown. That is a bad day.

• Eight of those catches were by Green. That matchup is on Dick LeBeau, not Taylor. It shouldn’t have taken place in 2014. It was fantasyland. It was wishing. Hoping. That’s not winning thinking.

• Don’t underestimate the potential impact of Ben Roethlisberger completing a 95-yard touchdown pass, especially in the extraordinary manner in which he pulled it off, heaving the ball from 2 yards behind the goal line and all the way out to the Pittsburgh 48.

Fifty yards in the air!

Can’t watch this play enough. It’s as beautiful as the great game of football gets.

Anyway, the point here: You will never see Roethlisberger celebrate a TD quite like he does those. And you will never see a smile on his face as broad as when he’s describing one of those. He’s a big-play QB at heart. Lives for it. Should bode well for Atlanta.

• Oh, about that wrist: “I tried to tell everyone all week that there was no issue.”

I would say that Bleacher Report’s self-proclaimed ‘injury expert’ owes Roethlisberger and the Steelers a retraction and/or apology, but the joke was on whoever took that stuff seriously.

• If we’re going to rip Tomlin and Todd Haley when they pull all the sideways/passive stuff, it’s fair to acknowledge this terrific — if cliched — answer from Tomlin about going for the bomb there: “We were just not going to live in our fears today. We needed to be aggressive and create some splash. It worked out for us.”

It could work more often, too.

• Consider how casually Martavis Bryant describes it …

• David DeCastro earned a ton of accolades for his pull blocking, including on this site. But the best blockers weren’t offensive linemen on this day. Matt Spaeth not only caught two passes but also posted a 3.1 run block rating that was best on the team. Second was fellow tight end Heath Miller at 1.7. And the best overall blocker, as is becoming the case week after week now, was Kelvin Beachum at a golden 4.1

Man, what a find Beachum has been. And credit, too, to Mike Munchak for instilling the technique and smarts any undersized offensive lineman needs to succeed.

• Stephon Tuitt played all but eight snaps. It’s about time. You saw it. He was solid against the run and had a QB hit — a nasty one at that, crushing Andy Dalton in the ribs — and a hurry, too.

• Ryan Shazier suited up and watched. Never played a down.

• I’d mention how red-faced the Steelers’ front office must have been to have their third-round pick this year (Dri Archer) and fourth-round pick last year (Landry Jones) healthy and inactive — not to mention Shazier suited up and just watching — except that their second-rounder last year is buying those gentlemen a whole lot of good will these days.

• Tomlin signaled that the Steelers would go for a two-point conversion immediately after Arthur Moats recovered Dalton’s fumble at the Cincinnati 24 early in the fourth quarter.

Did the TV show that?

That’s some serious red-zone confidence right there.

• The Steelers’ top four rated defenders with 300 or more snaps, in order: Cam Hewyard, Lawrence Timmons, James Harrison … and Moats. On the pass rush alone, Moats has four sacks, three QB hits and 14 hurries.

• One simply has not experienced all that is ‘AFC North football,’ as Roethlisberger and others were calling it, until watching that famous escalator above the riverside open end and the fans sadly riding it down, heads hanging, no music playing. The ‘Escalosers,’ as those who dislike the Bengals call it.

The Penguins and Pirates have a couple of good rivalries, but the Steelers’ setup, with an entire division of teams they know so well and dislike so much, is without parallel.

Just thought I’d share the very thought I had in riding one of those Escalosers out of the place myself.